| Evangel University | High | Player(s) | Opponent | Date | |
| Points | 24 | Mitch McHenry | vs Central Methodist (Mo.) | 10/27/2012 | |
| Touchdowns | 4 | Mitch McHenry | vs Central Methodist (Mo.) | 10/27/2012 | |
| Total Offensive Yards | 371 | Andrew Brimhall | vs Central Methodist (Mo.) | 10/27/2012 | |
| Total Offensive Plays | 56 | Andrew Brimhall | vs Missouri Valley | 11/03/2012 | |
| Rushing Yards | 184 | Tommy Meyer | vs Benedictine (Kan.) | 09/29/2012 | |
| Rushing Attempts | 24 | Tommy Meyer | vs Benedictine (Kan.) | 09/29/2012 | |
| Rushing TDs | 3 | Tommy Meyer | vs Benedictine (Kan.) | 09/29/2012 | |
| Longest Rush | 74 | Otis Brown | vs Culver-Stockton (Mo.) | 09/15/2012 | |
| Passing Yards | 371 | Andrew Brimhall | vs Benedictine (Kan.) | 09/29/2012 | |
| Passing Attempts | 43 | Andrew Brimhall | vs Missouri Valley | 11/03/2012 | |
| Passing TDs | 4 | Andrew Brimhall | vs Culver-Stockton (Mo.) | 09/15/2012 | |
| 4 | Andrew Brimhall | vs Central Methodist (Mo.) | 10/27/2012 | ||
| Longest Pass | 81 | Andrew Brimhall | vs Baker (Kan.) | 09/08/2012 | |
| Passes Completed | 25 | Andrew Brimhall | vs Central Methodist (Mo.) | 10/27/2012 | |
| Had Intercepted | 5 | Andrew Brimhall | vs Missouri Valley | 11/03/2012 | |
| Receiving Yards | 211 | Jesse Vaughn | vs Benedictine (Kan.) | 09/29/2012 | |
| Receptions | 11 | Mitch McHenry | vs Central Methodist (Mo.) | 10/27/2012 | |
| Receiving TDs | 4 | Mitch McHenry | vs Central Methodist (Mo.) | 10/27/2012 | |
| Longest Reception | 81 | Otis Brown | vs Baker (Kan.) | 09/08/2012 | |
| Field Goal Attempts | 5 | Drew O'Cain | vs Avila (Mo.) | 10/20/2012 | |
| Field Goals Made | 2 | Drew O'Cain | vs Friends (Kan.) | 09/01/2012 | |
| 2 | Drew O'Cain | vs Avila (Mo.) | 10/20/2012 | ||
| 2 | Drew O'Cain | vs Benedictine (Kan.) | 09/29/2012 | ||
| Longest Field Goal | 53 | Drew O'Cain | vs Benedictine (Kan.) | 09/29/2012 | |
| PAT Kick Attempts | 7 | Drew O'Cain | vs Central Methodist (Mo.) | 10/27/2012 | |
| 7 | Drew O'Cain | vs Avila (Mo.) | 10/20/2012 | ||
| 7 | Drew O'Cain | vs Benedictine (Kan.) | 09/29/2012 | ||
| PAT Kicks Made | 7 | Drew O'Cain | vs Central Methodist (Mo.) | 10/27/2012 | |
| PAT % | 100 | Jordan Bishop | vs Missouri Valley | 11/03/2012 | |
| 100 | Drew O'Cain | vs Peru State (Neb.) | 10/13/2012 | ||
| 100 | Drew O'Cain | vs Baker (Kan.) | 09/08/2012 | ||
| 100 | Drew O'Cain | vs Central Methodist (Mo.) | 10/27/2012 | ||
| 100 | Drew O'Cain | vs Graceland (Iowa) | 10/06/2012 | ||
| Punts | 8 | Josh Booker | vs Graceland (Iowa) | 10/06/2012 | |
| Longest Punt | 56 | Josh Booker | vs Graceland (Iowa) | 10/06/2012 | |
| Punt Returns | 2 | Tyrell Hemingway | vs Culver-Stockton (Mo.) | 09/15/2012 | |
| 2 | Denzel Pernell | vs Culver-Stockton (Mo.) | 09/15/2012 | ||
| 2 | Jesse Vaughn | vs Avila (Mo.) | 10/20/2012 | ||
| 2 | Jesse Vaughn | vs Peru State (Neb.) | 10/13/2012 | ||
| Punt Return Yards | 33 | Jesse Vaughn | vs Benedictine (Kan.) | 09/29/2012 | |
| Longest Punt Return | 33 | Jesse Vaughn | vs Benedictine (Kan.) | 09/29/2012 | |
| Punt Return TDs | 1 | Zach Reed | vs Avila (Mo.) | 10/20/2012 | |
| Kick Returns | 4 | Denzel Pernell | vs Nicholls | 09/22/2012 | |
| Kick Return Yards | 78 | Otis Brown | vs Peru State (Neb.) | 10/13/2012 | |
| Longest Kick Return | 50 | Denzel Pernell | vs Friends (Kan.) | 09/01/2012 | |
| Kick Return TDs | 0 | ||||
| Interceptions | 1 | Lamar Allen | vs Friends (Kan.) | 09/01/2012 | |
| 1 | Denzel Billy | vs Benedictine (Kan.) | 09/29/2012 | ||
| 1 | Cam Bruffett | vs Benedictine (Kan.) | 09/29/2012 | ||
| 1 | Cam Bruffett | vs Missouri Valley | 11/03/2012 | ||
| 1 | Cam Bruffett | vs Peru State (Neb.) | 10/13/2012 | ||
| Interception Return Yards | 58 | Cam Bruffett | vs Peru State (Neb.) | 10/13/2012 | |
| Longest Interception Return | 58 | Cam Bruffett | vs Peru State (Neb.) | 10/13/2012 | |
| Interception Return TDs | 1 | Denzel Pernell | vs Avila (Mo.) | 10/20/2012 | |
| Tackles | 17 | Denzel Billy | vs Peru State (Neb.) | 10/13/2012 | |
| Sacks | 3 | Stephen Swillum | vs Missouri Valley | 11/03/2012 | |
| TFL | 3 | Preston Henry | vs Culver-Stockton (Mo.) | 09/15/2012 | |
| 3 | Jamail Randle | vs Avila (Mo.) | 10/20/2012 | ||